The Whale Sharks and Oslob’s Controversy
Sixth Edition of Marine Life monthly post. My apology for the delay than its usual date on the 19th. Please join the polling on this post, share your opinion on this controversial issue!
It is very common for some nature lovers, travelers, and scuba divers to dream seeing whale sharks in their natural habitat, the ocean. It is not surprising, the whale shark is the world’s largest fish and one of the celebrities from the marine life world. The whale sharks are not dangerous to humans. It is a shark species (not a whale!) but they are not aggressive and very slow swimmers (5 kmph). However, with an average weight of 20 tons, the shark has a very powerful tail that could cause serious injury if get smashed at!
Their life span is not confirmed. Some suggested that they could live up to 150 years and start to breed at the age of 30 years. This means the whale sharks have to survive staying alive for 30 years before they start reproducing. Sadly, there are still greedy people chasing them for consumption, additionally, some fishing practices have posed a danger to their living survival. There were some reports on how the whale sharks trapped in fishermen’s nets that caused injuries and even death.
Where to see the Whale Sharks
As migratory animals, the whale sharks can be seen in many parts of the world. Whale shark is a solitary animal, but the shark found easily as a group on the area where there are lots of plankton – they eat plankton, small fish, and squid by sucking them.
Lonely Planet has listed places where we can spot them – let me quote the list in short summary (for details, please visit the Lonely Planet’s link):
- Donsol, the Philippines (February to April)
- Gladden Spit, Belize (March to June)
- Isla Holbox, Mexico (June to September)
- Koh Tao, Thailand (April to June)
- Ningaloo Reef, Australia (March – July)
- South Ari Toll, Maldives (May to December)
- South Mahe, Seychelles (October)
- Tofo, Mozambique (October to March)
- Utila, Honduras (March and April)
Additionally, there are places that not mentioned in Lonely Planet’s list but the whale sharks are spotted on these places as well:
- Darwin Island – Galapagos, Ecuador (June to October)
- Honda Bay – Palawan, the Philippines (April to November)
- Isla Mujeres, Mexico (May to September)
- Oslob – Cebu, the Philippines (all year round due to the feeding)
- Mafia Island, Tanzania (October to March)
- Nabire – Cenderawasih Bay National Park, Indonesia (May to October)
Update 27 February 2015
– Las Paz Baja – Mexico
The Whale Sharks (Unnatural) Feeding in Oslob
The Philippines is a popular country to see the whale sharks. At least, there are three areas where the whale sharks could be seen: Donsol, Palawan, and Oslob. The Philippines government is even featuring the Whale Sharks (butanding in local language) drawing on 100 peso banknotes/bill. The whale shark is an important asset for tourism in the Philippines.
While to see the sharks in Donsol and Palawan is possible on specific months, in Oslob is totally different. The presence of the whale sharks in Oslob is all year round due to the feeding by humans. The fishermen are luring the sharks to water area of depth approx 10 meters near to the shoreline. The fishermen fed sergestid shrimps to the sharks with their hands while paddling a small boat.
All is organized by the locals and supported by the local government. Currently the area is claimed as protected area and no motorboats allowed. It is well organized. The entrance fee includes safety vest, boat trip, and shower. Before going to the boat, we have to follow a briefing about the whale sharks.
The briefing includes some regulations to follow such as:
- Do not touch the whale sharks or harm them otherwise you will risk of prison up to six months and fine
- No camera flash allowed
- No body lotion and sunscreen allowed – if you already used it, then take shower before swimming/snorkeling
- Six people maximum on a boat (with two local guides) and 30 minutes allowed to swim or snorkel with the whale sharks – the guides will let you know
- Always take distance from the whale sharks
The regulations were reasonable. However, the first and the last ones were rather impossible to do in practice. I saw few guys tried to touch the whale sharks. Additionally it was too many people – I think there were around 10 boats with average six people on the boat – so imagine of 40 people (the two guides stayed on the boat) were swimming and snorkeling with huge expectation to see the whale sharks. Not to mention the scuba divers down there. It was too crowded to take distance from the whale sharks. The crowds – as some have feared – could stress the animals.
The Cons of Feedings in Oslob
After experiencing it myself, I understand why the environmentalists have concerns on the feeding practice. There are several critics that should be considered for the long-run practice in Oslob.
First concern is the feeding through boats might cause the whale sharks more vulnerable to fishing. It might cause the sharks to keep approaching boats for food. It will be bad news for them if the boats belong to those greedy and irresponsible people. Or other lousy case; they approach the fishermen boats and get entangled inside the fishing nets.
Second concern is, the luring might slowing down the migratory and disturb the reproduction process. It is not natural for the whale sharks to come closer to the shorelines like in Oslob, additionally they are slow swimmers so this critic makes sense to me.
The Pros of Feedings in Oslob
The presence of the whale sharks in Oslob generates good income for the villagers who also fishermen. It will be difficult to stop the practice entirely without providing the villagers alternate income resources. Besides to that, I was told long before the feeding, the whale sharks were already visiting the area to ate the fishermen’s shrimps baits for fishing. The sharks attracted by the shrimps for food. The local fishermen attacked the whale sharks to leave the Oslob waters since that ruined the fishing business. Such practice was far worse than what the fishermen do now.
Another defensive opinion, the practice in Oslob is lesser evil if being compared to longer practices committed by huge organizations like Sea Life and other huge sea-aquariums or zoo around the world that put the wilds in captivity. In Oslob, at least, the whale sharks are free to come and leave.
The Future of Oslob
Before deciding to visit Oslob, I had long discussion with Miia from Pearlspotting who loves whale sharks and had multiple encounters with the sharks. I am thanking her for her point of views and information about the sharks. I had never seen one and I was about to visit Moalboal which was not far from Oslob. It was a dilemma for me. I have been reading about the supports and the condemns before my visit. In the end I decided to go otherwise how can I judge if I have never seen it?
I admitted that I enjoyed seeing the whale sharks in Oslob. However it was with guilt feeling. I love the opportunity seeing the sharks but at the same time I dislike the ideas that the practices might impact negatively to their lives in the wild. I am worried if the critics were correct, we put the sharks in more vulnerable conditions. On the other hand, to discontinue this type of tourism, we will take away the earnings of the locals and maybe the past will repeat that the fishermen have to confront against the sharks for ruining their livelihoods, unless there are sustainable fishing methods introduced to assist the local fishermen.
I have no real solutions for this matter. I guess to stop the practice in the end will depend on the demands and majority public opinion as well. Would you visit Oslob to see the whale sharks? Please let me know via the following polling. I will not judge your choice, and thank you for your vote.
- The whale shark status is vulnerable – close to endanger status as the number of whale sharks keep reducing annually – IUCN Red List
- The location is in Tan-Awan village, Oslob. It can be reached from Cebu (around two hours) or Moalboal (one hour)
- The feeding starts at 8 am until 12 am
- Wear swimming suits upon arrival – the number of changing rooms is limited
- Do not use any body creme/lotion nor sunscreen beforehand
- The cost is 500 pesos for locals and 1000 pesos for foreigners
- Snorkel set is available for rent – I find using fins are helpful to get faster swimming and free diving
For scuba divers:
- Scuba diving costs 3000 pesos (includes equipment)
- Most dive centers in the Philippines are against the feeding practice in Oslob, please do not expect or force the services from certain dive centers to bring you to Oslob
- It is better to snorkel and do bit of free-diving than scuba diving due to shallow waters
so interesting to read and go through your photos, Indah…for some of us this is as close as it can get to real scuba-diving experience 🙂
when did you start scuba-diving and how did you get inspired to do this? 🙂
Hi Alexandra, thank you so much! I had my scuba diving license five years ago in Belize and I had wonderful diving there that since then our holidays changed to diving holidays 😀 I will share the story someday 🙂
Hmmm… quite the dilemma, Indah. I’m not sure I agree with creating an unnatural attraction for the whale sharks… especially if it puts them in longer term danger.
It is a dilemma – I am afraid all things related to humans, their livelihoods and natures in the end put the whole situation more complicated 😦
gorgeous photos 🙂
Thank you Joshi!
Great post on the Whale Sharks. I actually went to Oslob and Donsol two years ago. I did not see them in Donsol, but was lucky to go to Oslob. I agree the feeding thing is controversial, but I think the fact that different sharks come and go, and its not always the same one is beneficial. Plus the fisherman used to kill these lovely fish.
Heres a post I did on them.
Thanks Michael! That’s my concern as well, they were not the same whale sharks – probably Oslob is already famous among them so they stop by for free meal during their way to Maldives or Japan 😉
I have friends who tried to look for them in Donsol with no luck as well 😦 I wonder whether the whale sharks are still passing by on that area 😦
I can really understand why this is such a controversial topic…and while I’d like nothing better to see these incredible whales in their natural environment ~ for now it seems that Oslobs is a reasonable alternative…and I would truly love to see these amazing creatures. Great post Indah ~ I hope the winter season is treating you well 🙂 I’m off to Munich in a few days for an outdoor show (ISPO)…hoping for sunny weather!
Great post on whale sharks..thanks for the share Indah…
Wunderschöne Bilder lieber Gruß und einen schönen Donnerstag Gruß Gislinde
Great post on whale sharks, Indah!! Have these photos been clicked by you? They are amazing.
Hi, my apology for just replying now..yes, they were. Thank you so much! I take pictures underwater and Dutchie is making the movies 🙂